This article will attempt to describe the issues involved with trying to correlate CMM measurement with Surface Plate and/or Handheld equipment inspection. The example part here has a greatly exaugurated error on the RH surface for clarity. The view is 2D to simplify the description, but this applies directly to 3D.
CMM Measurement
The LH and RH surfaces are inspected as planes with many points over each surface. The resulting surfaces are calculated based on a Least Squares Best Fit. (Other fits are available). This results in the best fit surface indicated on the RH side.
The distance reported is the distance between the two best fit surfaces as shown.
Surface Plate
The part is placed on a surface plate with the RH side down and a height gage is used to inspect the LH (now top) side. The part will sit on the three high points when placed on the surface plate resulting in an effective "plane" as shown for the RH side.
Not only will the distance be based on the 3 high points plane that the part rests on; depending on where the height gage is used on the LH (top) surface, different results may be obtained. None of these are equivalent to the CMM calculations.
Hand Held (Calipers)
Calipers are used at various points along the surfaces as shown. Once again, different readings will result depending on the exact location the readings where taken. Most of these will not be equivalent to the CMM calculations.
The resulting distances will be 2D only and based on whatever 2 points are contacted by the calipers or other handheld device.
Summary
It is normal for CMM results to not exactly equal results from a surface plate or handheld measurement. The methods and the data points are not equivilent.
- The CMM uses best fit calculations based on a spread of points over the inspected feature in 3D.
- The surface plate will use the 3 high points on the surface in contact with the surface plate and be a 3D evaluation.
- Handheld inspection will use the two points that are contacted by the handheld device and since only 2 points are used, will be a 2D result.